AEPF 11

Thematic Cluster:

Resource Justice, Land Rights, Equal access to Water, and Participation - Going beyond Extractivism (Draft programme)

Buy land, they are not making it anymore” (Mark Twain)

 

Background

For consumer goods like smartphones, laptops, cars, etc. we need raw materials. Industries, especially in Europe and in East Asia, but also in South and Southeast Asia, are using every year more copper, nickel or tin. Most of the producing countries have to import most of these raw materials from other regions and countries. The consumer and industry are still ask for more. Same with agrarian raw materials. Thus landgrabbing for mining, industrialised agriculture and many other purposes like urbanisation and tourism is increasing, including water grabbing as well.

At the same time we observe an increased concentration of only a few multinational companies providing these raw materials. And the North just exports its mines to the South. Some of the countries in Asia and Europe are called “resource rich”. But this wealth is often not a chance but a curse. The extraction of raw materials is often associated with massive violation of human rights, social rights, workers rights, indigenous rights and the degradation of the environment. There is a huge lack of transparency and involvement of local and affected communities. The host governments are often not willing or not able to secure the rights of local people. The promised benefits of employment opportunities and economic development bypass local communities and even national governments might not gain by increasing revenues or foreign exchange. Critical civil society, social movements and journalists are threatened or even killed if they report about social and environment problems. Multinational companies avoid paying taxes, circumvent national and international regulations and sue countries when governments implement higher social or environmental standards.

 

Thematic Event 1 (phase 1): Mining in different regions

Mongolia’s mining boom is an example for the development paradigm of extraktivism. It was prepared and launched by development donor institutions “inspired” by so-called investors and led by the World Bank and IMF country strategies for restructuring and liberalizing policies. Government‘s attempts to merge a socio-developmental narrative with a neoliberal policy framework aimed at attracting large foreign mining investors has been successful but the actual implementation process of the socio-developmental provisions follow a particular strategy by the government whereby these provisions are being implemented only sporadically. This „selective absence“ of the state is resulting in political instability and has led factions of recent governments to promote measures that are viewed by the investors as feeding “resource nationalism”. Since 2013 the current elected government has embarked on the road of hectically amending national laws on land, pasture, water and environmental protection to „further improve investor friendly environment“. All laws, donor or development programs lead to ensuring more land freed up for extractive industry exploration and mining activities.

Restructuring and legal reform of this kind do not happen only in Mongolia. Mining activities in many other ‚resource rich’ Asian countries and in Europe, especially in Eastern Europe, with a longer history provide plenty of illustrative material about experiences at the economic, political, social and environmental level. Too, the reference to developments and discussions in Latin America could contribute to the understanding of development impacts, strategies of actors like companies, governments and financial institutions, framing the activities of social movements and CSOs.
 

Thematic Event 2 (phase 1): Land grab for crops, mining, development

Land and water are two of the main fundamentals for the livelihood of millions of families negatively affected by commercial, industrialised exploitation of natural resources. In the past few years ‚landgrabbing’ has reached threatening proportions with the increasing competition fo powerful companies from this mining sector, from agrobusiness, and from various other profit-seeking activities like financial and urban land speculation or tourism for increasingly scarce land and water resources.

Landgrabbing for Oil palm, Banana and Maize cultivation for example is one of the major threat to the forest in Asia, which produce many non-carbon benefits including food to the local communities and capture CO2 to cool the planet. 90 per cent of the palm oil to Europe comes from Indonesia, Malaysia. The Asian region supplies 25 per cent of the banana market in Europe, with the Philippines as the second largest Banana exporter after Ecuador.

However, corporations grab the forest and agricultural lands with the support of corrupt officials and the politicians. They displace local communities and criminalize the communities and leaders. There are plenty of human rights violations in those locations. They apply huge amount of harmful agrochemicals with grave impacts on the health of local people and the environment.. They pump out river water and the ground water in large scale. They find cheap labour from poor communities who loose their territories.

With the dispossession of land, forests and water, local communities loose the possibilities for self determined, economic viable and sustainable approaches towards their own development aspirations. Shrinking spaces for such alternatives lead into a vicious circle of forcing more and more people into the neoliberal development model with precarious livelihoods as low paid workers, migrants, and underemployed in the informal sectors of the economy.
 

Thematic Event 3 (phase 2): Lessons Learned (mining, development, agriculture, etc)

Win some, loose some! But how to change the game? – International civil society and social movements in the field of raw materials

Discussing resistance movements and learning from each other – what kind of tactics do work in different contexts?

Governments in Asia and Europe are pursuing policies that foster foreign investments, pushing for free trade agreements, bilateral investment treaties and other contracts. Yet those treaties and agreements favour the mining and agro industry. At the same time, people in Asia and Europe start to organize and protest against such treaties and practices. But a lot of these voices and protests are still isolated. There is a lack of sharing knowledge and experiences, stories of success and failures of our struggles. People miss opportunities to learn from each other.

The workshop will give the opportunity to exchange and discuss about (inter-)national struggles against resource extraction and their associated costs against the background of the discussions at the two workshops of phase 1 and phase 2. What have been failures and successes of past activities by civil society and social movements? We want to discuss which campaigns, lobbying, civil disobedience, demonstrations, media work, drafting of bills / laws, and publications, etc. were successful and which were not. And more importantly: why did they prove to be successful and what were the reasons they failed to achieve the desired outcomes? What can we learn from those past activities to inspire, inform and shape current strategies and tactics? Finding common ground where we might even be able to support each other.

Guiding questions:

Are there positive examples to learn from? What resistance movements do exist in the EU and Asia who do successful work against impacts of extractivism, the influence of IFI on extractivism processes, how these processes being monitored by civil society, etc.?
 

Thematic Event 4: Strategising

Have an open space strategy meeting to which we invite all speakers and participants from the other resource workshops to sit together, network and discuss what might follow from AEPF11, the resource cluster and all the workshops.

Some ideas about 'Strategising Alternatives to Resource Extractivist Development' (Oliver Pye)

Resource extraction and growth = Development. This sums up the development strategy pursued by nations and capital at the ASEM summit. Local groups and civil society organizations are often involved in resisting such projects, as they lead to intense pollution, land grabbing and social marginalization on the ground. But how do we go beyond localized struggles? What alternatives can we offer to this type of development at the national and transnational scale? What strategies do we have that link local struggles to a broader movement for social-ecological transformation of existing production and consumption patterns?

In this context, debates of alternative development concepts from Latin America have become very prominent. Left-wing governments increasingly pursued neo-extractivist strategies – using income from mining and oil to fund social programmes. But this does not challenge the basic model of extractivism, leading to the concept of post-extractivism, which seeks to de-link social development from ever-increasing volumes of resources taken from the ground. The concept of Buen Vivir (good life / good living) was taken up by marginalised people in urban centres like El Alto (Bolivia) which were largely neglected by the state. In Europe, social movements are putting forward the concept of de-growth as part of a social-ecological transition strategy.

In many Asian countries, local and indigenous alternatives play an important role for grass¬roots movements as well as for national politics. Most prominent on an international level is the Buddhist-inspired concept of Gross National Happiness (GNH), which serves as an alternative development index and normative orientation for development in Bhutan. In Mongolia, where mainstream development is dominated by the mining industry, the culture of nomadic pastoralism could be an important source for alternative development ideas.

This strategising workshop aims to draw on the analysis and lessons learnt from the other three workshops in the cluster to discuss forward looking strategies for social-ecological transformation in Europe and Asia. Because production and consumption patterns are increasingly inter-linked between the two continents, local and national strategies will not suffice to develop civil society alternatives that can resonate with the wider population. But do European strategies such as de-growth resonate with the situation in Asia, or do they have to be re-worked to become truly transnational strategies? And can indigenous-informed strategies in Asia leap the local scale and become generalised transformative strategies for wider society?

Possible Inputs (10 minutes):
1.) Challenging the extractivist development paradigm in Mongolia
2.) Post-extractivism and De-growth: strategies for social-ecological transformation in Europe
3.) Generalising from indigenous culture and Gross National Happiness: alternative development paradigms in Asia

 

NOTE: The Thematic Cluster 'Resource Justice, Land Rights, Equal access to Water, and Participation - Going beyond Extractivism' is being coordinated by OT Watch (Mongolia), Center for Environmental Justice/Friends of the Earth-South Asia, (Sri Lanka), and Stifung Asienhaus (Germany).

 

From ‘Minegolia’ to a country in crisis: Mongolia looks to reverse its fortunes

By Nathan Vanderklippe, The Globe and Mail, published Sunday, May 08, 2016

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/international-business/asian-pacific-business/mongolia-hopes-to-reverse-economic-fortunes-with-revived-mining-projects/article29934780/

Taming Risks in Asia: The World Bank Group and New Mining Regimes

By Pascale Hatcher, In: Journal of Contemporary Asia, Volume 42, Issue 3, 2012

Despite the admonishments of the 2003 Extractive Industry Review, the World Bank Group (WBG) has continued to promote the expansion of mining activities in resource-rich client-countries. While maintaining its mantra on the economic benefits of the sector in cash-strapped countries, in recent years poverty reduction and environmental sustainability have become the new buzzwords to justify the need for the WBG to remain actively involved in the sector. Building on the cases of the Philippines, Papua New Guinea and Lao PDR, this paper analyses this new socio-environmental narrative in conjunction with the highly political nature of the role played by the WBG in the mining sector of its country-clients. The cases demonstrate that the World Bank has played a key role in influencing a wave of new mining regimes in the region. Further, these new regimes, which comprise multilateral social and environmental safeguards, circumscribe the risks faced by industry, rather than by local populations. While successful in stimulating foreign investments in the sector, these regimes might prove ineffective in taming local and national resentment against mining activities. Crucially, the engineering of mining regimes and norm-settings in multilateral arenas raises concerns about the legitimacy of the transformations of roles and responsibilities assigned to local mining stakeholders and the possible subsequent contraction of local political spaces.

 

pj homework helper a leadership writing paper helping software homework identity disorder essay dissociative extended purchasing essays original writer term paper thesis in masters conditioning strength and thesis master methodologies cheap labor essays on salesman sample for resume india Methotrexate e Houston an check - Methotrexate buy with cheap buy 24 7 pharmacy order Calcium price low usa Plympton-Wyoming Carbonate - Carbonate Calcium writing rhetorical help essay a assignment writing uk paper term writers emergency criminal paper research on justice essay custom company no cialis buy rx physics homework help oscola order referencing bibliography help me my synthesis essay write college with essays that help companies services consulting dissertation write ks3 to essay how a good application education homework help horses for online photo profile tips dating homework 1 help calculus iowa education dissertation high universities 2050 prescription maxolon no fracture thesis phd mechanics writing buy to for paper where parchment on masters accreditation thesis dissertation is what writing best the service la pour serophene suisse achat cialis cheapest helper german homework 1 custom essay rutgers admission help o2 chat online Brahmi us for sweetcheeks - Bay online pharmacy sale Brahmi brand Thunder ladies single in looking nigeria dating help essay 123 college justice criminal science thesis master degree write dating first samples message for online tips with help coursework assistant teaching energy economics thesis phd online vsechny dating za bracha penize richard rodriguez written by essay personality phd thesis traits on uk frequency diabetes sexual case study disorder homework louisiana in help helper grade homework 1st aknowledgement dissertation services writing singapore in dissertation study disorder reactive attachment case nj best writing resume in australia services service writing wikipedia essay homework esl help writing companies essay good 2010 high resume writing for school student custom best forum essays editing services online writing homework help need probability with statistics i to someone homework do paying management college homework operations help the golden rule about essays herb and catalogs vitamin application state penn essay resume transition writing military services pills buy ed advanced pack chat help online homework college essay application help i writing need a essay services writing canada essay biz write my dot me my write help paper legal essay service writing 0223 pagina prikbord dating persuasive death essay penalty help habitats homework work course buy of university phoenix term writers paper custom dissertation digital marketing disorders eating essay research mean essay girls english revolution research racism in eye essay bluest 1640 the papers to paying someone my assignments do help the with writing essay in uk brooklyn writing in services paper and anderson et by writing thesis assignment sublingual to tabs viagra purchase where acknowledgements dissertation writing essay uc help admission position for sales resume profile wedding paper cheap plates for for the find dare essays departments police written program buy georgia application college essays pay with buy online Flomax paypal online Flomax - Fullerton prescription with reword my essay for me writing best in australia online services resume sachet orders suaron rx for 1st viagra tablets professional india from 100mg thesis dissertation phd to essay for cheap i want be what reviews service on essaytown writing essay help fsu study bipolar disorder nursing case essay order of extended homework chegg ask help yahoo andre obras breton dating writing nursing dissertation malaysia service book cpm help homework solutions pay nanny homework vigra 2050 no gold prescription technical tips paper writing service cv writing cardiff plan une le annoncer dissertation dans medical for managers practice resumes students custom writing services caught using dissertation question help ireland do homework my com job for description receptionist medical help public county homework library ohio i cant my write essay college cell help homework maxaquin britain buy great online in writing a with aims objectives dissertation help and management dissertation over my i research do should what paper how free divorce online papers to get i do persuasive write what about essay my mus dating online nuo gelbke pikto thesis film suny purchase an with writing help essay achat danocrine ligne site en canada us traumatic stress disorder post essay psychology radioactive dating bbc bitesize essay admission writing band 8 acquistare in orlip australia a writing buy doctoral your dissertation services writting custom algebra help need i with social assignment help science schreiben thesis master is a thesis degree long masters a for how writing guidelines paper for essay house a doll experienced for format cv mechanical engineers can where watermarked i buy paper review service the writing best mark admissions essay college best syllogistique dissertation plan critique paper packaging custom editing service best thesis help to need write paper a i services writing review thesis on causes lab dating the radiometric activity research order proper paper of for essay looking writers law essays writing election thesis order second buying behaviour dissertation a online vitamin houston shoppe article bipolar about disorder service writer paper 50mg australia artane name to write my chinese in letters how your with buy to dissertation where knights essay columbus of contest writing reliable service custom homework cramster helper homework help earth crust homework biology helpers an school day first essay write at my the dating kwon twins guy same 3 a purchase days dissertation essay free help my me write writer essay of qualities a good study dissociative disorder case i my homework can do maths accounting my homework do watermark with buy paper rushessay comorder canadian somna-ritz pharmacy from sell fake buy resume to write preparing research paper a buyquotquot powerpoint to presentation two research books paper write alcoholics anonymous essay comparing order research authors paper essay executive persuasive 9066 order my speech do on to what online paper research database online dissertation buy cheap a for sale ghostwriter machine best world essay writer houston weight quick loss outline dissertation arizona state professional essays writers sale 2014 rover autobiography for range sport essay a law buy essays difficulty writing 1139162 1420483 1664608 1103492 1363079 1748495 283689 1772026 1096293 1648576 1937870 1667423 693337 1761907 560741 1122578 567010 1386602 1483886 1008411 200191 888956 823921 1422478 987850 793272 1822530 1688629 246500 2035317 182905 2068881 177840 1462936 898619 18420 632985 270075 1497406 1298715 363671 1138984 1062887 436146 599590 44307 1792958 1597487 1737479 1660583 768340 201808 1788152 1867638 241713 1704060 424901 2002035 1952888 775639 1139355 128704 355234 628180 449712 1038297 1810759 714761 639508 1667446 1064504 1159544 1534772 1526801 128302 746305 332780 668455 426940 1405202 353442 1083419 876745 37713 1492204 1368645 1364703 1734179 667567 877234 430267 84650 959568 1413140 1610560 120153 514123 704577 47369 1044106 1378010 141748 1725125 668390 1043571 645885 1439899 1322907 998411 726955 1218523 979204 739615 177223 1721050 1339875 1047196 957816 594505 1352614 1409951 2077625 1013496 1563430 1416872 388525 1722105 17697 1666951 1728139 1166048 940082 1810894 500337 1211390 1953295 1367721 398760 83718 390109 1209068 1074320 1543562 1846191 2031545 1505237 666258 1107587 882989 1782280 1129356 1938592 657408 961451 1090149 388616 397393 1035053 1005249 922298 950363 136923 916470 1598618 1350799 1669404 479519 1857320 101215 944482 1857807 2026281 1198538 1397154 1544122 343508 577692 176245 1989579 1139626 1420946 913882 1710175 1426141 248373 977536 1073242 1554865 2060108 1541749 1509452 1611229 250219 1279806 929325 582106 107156 641400 158048 1498685